020 7246 6560 / info@hughmans.co.uk

Operation Cotton: FCA fail to secure fraud convictions across the board

19th June 2015

The extraordinary saga of Operation Cotton – the first prosecution by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) – came to an end with the failure of the FCA to secure convictions across the board against all defendants.

The FCA prosecuted 8 defendants for offences relating to the fraudulent sale of land to members of the public using so-called ‘boiler room’ tactics. The defendants ranged from organisers to salesmen to administrators for the string of companies involved in the fraud.

Lee Adams acted for 4 out of the 8 defendants in Operation Cotton, including the company administrator and 3 salesmen.

Although the FCA secured convictions against all defendants charged with operating a Collective Investment Scheme – a little used provision of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 with a maximum term of imprisonment of 2 years – it failed to achieve convictions for the headline offence of conspiracy to defraud against several defendants, including two represented by Hughmans.

Counsel instructed were:-

Chris Gillespie and Vivienne Tanchel of 2 Hare Court for the defendant Forsyth;

David Whittaker and Harry Bentley of 2 Hare Court for the defendant Peters;

Leon Kazakos of 187 Fleet Street and Christopher Ware of 2 Hare Court for the defendant Hawkins; and

Samantha Cohen and Richard Paton-Philip of 9 Bedford Row for the defendant Mitchie

More articles


Complex fraud case stopped after Hughmans successfully argues there can be no fair trial

Lee Adams successfully argued for a stay of complex fraud proceedings known as R v Crawley & Others at Southwark Crown Court today alongside Alexander Cameron QC. The case is the first to be stayed as a result of the Government’s cuts to Legal Aid, which left the defendants with no prospect of adequate representation […]

Read more

Significant Hughmans win

Asad Ali Meerza and others v Tareq Al Baho and others [2015] EWHC 3154 (Ch) Following nearly five years of hard fought litigation in various jurisdictions Hughmans have obtained a ruling against fraudster Tareq Al Baho, who had made a secret profit on the sale of a property belonging to the estate of a deceased […]

Read more

Precedent set on state immunity

Hughmans have set a precedent on the doctrine of state immunity. The Court of Appeal have ruled in favour of Hughmans’ client in an appeal from the Chancery Division of the High Court. The Court of Appeal confirmed the decision of the High Court in finding that there was no state immunity for the estate […]

Read more