020 7246 6560 / info@hughmans.co.uk

Operation Cotton: FCA fail to secure fraud convictions across the board

19th June 2015

The extraordinary saga of Operation Cotton – the first prosecution by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) – came to an end with the failure of the FCA to secure convictions across the board against all defendants.

The FCA prosecuted 8 defendants for offences relating to the fraudulent sale of land to members of the public using so-called ‘boiler room’ tactics. The defendants ranged from organisers to salesmen to administrators for the string of companies involved in the fraud.

Lee Adams acted for 4 out of the 8 defendants in Operation Cotton, including the company administrator and 3 salesmen.

Although the FCA secured convictions against all defendants charged with operating a Collective Investment Scheme – a little used provision of the Financial Services and Markets Act 2000 with a maximum term of imprisonment of 2 years – it failed to achieve convictions for the headline offence of conspiracy to defraud against several defendants, including two represented by Hughmans.

Counsel instructed were:-

Chris Gillespie and Vivienne Tanchel of 2 Hare Court for the defendant Forsyth;

David Whittaker and Harry Bentley of 2 Hare Court for the defendant Peters;

Leon Kazakos of 187 Fleet Street and Christopher Ware of 2 Hare Court for the defendant Hawkins; and

Samantha Cohen and Richard Paton-Philip of 9 Bedford Row for the defendant Mitchie

More articles


Spitsbergen Retraced

Hughmans is proud to have been a sponsor of the Spitsbergen Retraced expedition team from Oxford University, which returned safely recently.  Expedition Leader James Lam contacted us to say:- “I am very happy to report that the expedition returned safely to Longyearbyen yesterday following a pick up from the Nordenskiold Glacier. Despite some rather questionable […]

Read more

Hughmans’ success in Britain’s biggest insider dealing case

Operation Tabernula, which has been widely reported, was the UK’s largest and most complex insider dealing prosecution. The FCA allegation involved a group of people who were party to dealing on inside information, from employees at investment banks to intermediaries and private traders. Records found at one of the defendant’s offices recorded 59 instances of […]

Read more

Hughmans prevent prosecution from lifting the corporate veil in confiscation case

Hughmans acted for established accountant and tax advisor Ernest Wayne Pulman in a high value confiscation case before the Cardiff Crown Court, successfully limiting Mr Pulman’s liability by preventing the prosecution from lifting the corporate veil. Mr Pulman was convicted of conspiracy to commit fraud, fraudulent trading, and conspiracy to steal after he began providing […]

Read more