020 7246 6560 / info@hughmans.co.uk

Hughmans’ success in Britain’s biggest insider dealing case

2nd June 2016

Operation Tabernula, which has been widely reported, was the UK’s largest and most complex insider dealing prosecution. The FCA allegation involved a group of people who were party to dealing on inside information, from employees at investment banks to intermediaries and private traders.

Records found at one of the defendant’s offices recorded 59 instances of trading, which the FCA said occurred in connection with the agreement to deal on inside information. They sought to prove on over 80% of occasions when trading took place, the investment bankers were employed to advise the companies whose stocks were traded. However the FCA relied on just six ‘overt’ acts of ‘insider dealing’, between November 2006 and March 2010, in different sectors of the market.

Peter Hughman (Lead Partner, Crime Department) acted for Mr Parvizi. He was assisted by Katie Kipps (Solicitor, Crime Department) and other members of the team. In addition to the extensive material gathered by Hughmans to support the defence, the team analysed hundreds of thousands of trading data entries, over 120 trading accounts, call data records, broker call recordings, hours of probe recordings, as well as over 46 lever arch files of evidence and some 80,000 items of unused material.

The 8 year investigation was branded a success by the FCA, but after a trial that lasted 12 weeks, they failed to secure convictions with respect to a number of defendants. After 11 days of deliberation by the jury, two defendants were found guilty of conspiracy to engage in insider dealing. Mr Parvizi and two others were acquitted. The two convicted defendants were sentenced to four and a half years and three and a half years. The maximum sentence for insider dealing in the UK is seven years imprisonment and/or an unlimited fine.

The FCA conducted the £14 million investigation, in partnership with the National Crime Agency (‘NCA’). The FCA were eager to point out that it is funded by the firms it regulates. It does not receive any funding from the Government. However the NCA, who assisted with the lengthy surveillance against the defendants, is publically funded.

The final cost to the public purse is unknown, but includes legal fees with respect to a number of publicly funded defendants and the cost of a 12 week jury trial, which is likely to be substantial.

The defendants who were acquitted and did not rely on public funds to defend themselves, throughout the 8 year investigation, are not entitled to any form of compensation or even the return of their legal costs.

Mr Parvizi put his case to investigators over 6 years ago, when he was arrested in March 2010, and provided a comprehensive prepared statement which set out the same defence that he explained to the jury throughout his trial.

Counsel instructed were Orlando Pownall QC and David Whittaker of 2 Hare Court.

More articles


When is a divorce ‘obtained in’ the British Islands?

Peter Black acted for a respondent in a case which considered whether a divorce certificate granted at the consulate of the Russian Federation in London amounted to a divorce ‘obtained in’ the British Islands for the purposes of section 44 (1) of the Family Law Act 1986. The Court ruled that the divorce had been […]

Read more

Precedent set on state immunity

Hughmans have set a precedent on the doctrine of state immunity. The Court of Appeal have ruled in favour of Hughmans’ client in an appeal from the Chancery Division of the High Court. The Court of Appeal confirmed the decision of the High Court in finding that there was no state immunity for the estate […]

Read more

Life After the FSA

Yesterday my colleague Luke Gittos and I attended the educational event organised by the Young Fraud Lawyers Association (YFLA) held at the Chambers of Simon Russell Flint QC. The event featured Christopher Coltart and Vivienne Tanchel, members of the Chambers of Orlando Pownall QC, discussing the regulatory landscape in the wake of the dissolution of […]

Read more